Personal tools
 
Views

Debate: Deporting illegal immigrants in the US

From Debatepedia

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
Revision as of 00:14, 30 April 2010 (edit)
Ifisher18 (Talk | contribs)
(Con)
← Previous diff
Revision as of 00:14, 30 April 2010 (edit)
Ifisher18 (Talk | contribs)
(Con)
Next diff →
Line 86: Line 86:
====Con==== ====Con====
*'''The Trail of Tears clearly demonstrates the injustice and hardship caused by mass deportation.''' *'''The Trail of Tears clearly demonstrates the injustice and hardship caused by mass deportation.'''
-'''As a world superpower, it is the duty of the United States to shield immigrants from hardship they may face in their home country. '''+*'''As a world superpower, it is the duty of the United States to shield immigrants from hardship they may face in their home country.'''
|- |-
|colspan="2" width="45%" bgcolor="#F2F2F2" style="border:1px solid #BAC5FD;padding:.4em;padding-top:0.5em;"| |colspan="2" width="45%" bgcolor="#F2F2F2" style="border:1px solid #BAC5FD;padding:.4em;padding-top:0.5em;"|

Revision as of 00:14, 30 April 2010

Should the US adopt policies to deport all illegal immigrants?

Background and context

Illegal immigration is a significant issue in the United States. While some advocate for deporting all illegal immigrants, as a matter of policies, others say it is too difficult, particularly in the context of there being 15 million of them.

Feasibility: Is mass deportation a viable option?

Pro

  • The US is capable of deporting all illegal immigrants. CNN’s Lou Dobbs said that, "When this president and open-borders, illegal-alien-amnesty advocates say, ‘You can’t deport them,’ my answer is, ‘You wanna bet?’ Because this is the United States."[1]
  • Deporting illegal immigrants in smaller numbers is feasible. Ian de Silva. "How to Deport 10 Million Illegal Aliens." Human Events. May 18th, 2006: "no one is seriously talking about mass deportation, for anyone with a modicum of common sense knows we could not round up all the illegal aliens at once. [...] However, we can round them up in smaller numbers, and over time, the cumulative effect of round-ups will have an undeniably deterrent effect."

Con

  • Deportation of nearly 12 million illegal immigrants would be impractical. To send 12 million illegal immigrants abroad by plane would require about 30,000 flights. To deport that many people by bus would be cheaper, but would still require 240,000 bus loads. Furthermore, these assumptions neglect both the possibility of trial, and the fact that illegal immigrants come from places other than Mexico.


History: How has mass deportation worked in the past?

Pro

  • Mass deportation under Operation Wetback was successful. Operation Wetback was very successful in the removal of nearly one million illegal immigrants from the United States in 1954.

Con

Economics: Will the deportation of all illegal immigrants support the economy?

Pro

Con

  • Mass deportation would be very expensive. The deportation of all illegal immigrants could cost American taxpayers up to $200 billion.


Morality: Is mass deportation of illegal immigrants morally acceptable?

Pro

  • Illegal aliens have no moral right to remain in the US. Ian de Silva. "How to Deport 10 Million Illegal Aliens." Human Events. May 18th, 2006: "As a legal immigrant and naturalized American who waited years for a green card, I mince no words when I say I have no sympathy whatsoever for illegal aliens. They have no right to be here, and their claim that their marches are the latest struggle in civil rights is poppycock. At this rate, a burglar who invades your house will have an equal claim of ownership to your house merely because he is inside the house."
  • Deporting illegal immigrants maintains moral goal of security. The primary purpose of the government is to maintain national security of its people. Deporting illegal immigrants, who potentially pose a security risk to US citizens, is potentially a matter of security. This is particularly true when referring to illegal aliens who commit crimes or who are suspected ties to terrorism.


Con

  • The Trail of Tears clearly demonstrates the injustice and hardship caused by mass deportation.
  • As a world superpower, it is the duty of the United States to shield immigrants from hardship they may face in their home country.

Constitutionality: Does the Constitution support the deportation of illegal immigrants?

Pro

  • The right to free movement only applies w/in borders. These rights are granted by the Constitution, so can only apply within the confines of those national, sovereign borders.


Con

  • Freedom of movement is an unalienable human right.



Opinion: Does public opinion support deporting illegal immigrants?

Pro

  • Some polls find Americans support deporting illegals.


Con

  • Americans oppose the deportation of illegal immigrants.

Pro/con sources

Pro


Con


See also

External links and resources

Problem with the site? 

Tweet a bug on bugtwits
.