Personal tools
 
Views

Debate: A right to die?

From Debatepedia

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
Revision as of 16:10, 15 July 2009 (edit)
Brooks Lindsay (Talk | contribs)
(Is prescribing lethal drugs to terminal patients justifiable?)
← Previous diff
Revision as of 16:11, 15 July 2009 (edit)
Brooks Lindsay (Talk | contribs)
(Is denial to grant right to die a power game?)
Next diff →
Line 59: Line 59:
====Yes==== ====Yes====
*'''[[Argument: Right to die annoys power-freaks| Right to die annoys power-freaks]]''' [http://blog.tp.org/woody/archives/002096.html "The right to die debate". Woody Cavenaugh,January 18, 2006 ]:"I always found it funny that people have a lot less trouble with killing someone, than letting someone kill themselves. Most states allow capital punishment, but to my knowledge only one or two allow assisted suicide, and only Oregon has a law allowing it outright.I believe it probably comes down to power. People want power over other people, governments want power over people, people and governments ultimately don't like it when other strange people can choose for themselves. I can do whatever I want, paint my house pink with green polka-dots for instance, but if YOU do it, I'm going homeowners association all over your weird butt." *'''[[Argument: Right to die annoys power-freaks| Right to die annoys power-freaks]]''' [http://blog.tp.org/woody/archives/002096.html "The right to die debate". Woody Cavenaugh,January 18, 2006 ]:"I always found it funny that people have a lot less trouble with killing someone, than letting someone kill themselves. Most states allow capital punishment, but to my knowledge only one or two allow assisted suicide, and only Oregon has a law allowing it outright.I believe it probably comes down to power. People want power over other people, governments want power over people, people and governments ultimately don't like it when other strange people can choose for themselves. I can do whatever I want, paint my house pink with green polka-dots for instance, but if YOU do it, I'm going homeowners association all over your weird butt."
-  
- 
-''Click on the pencil icon and research and write arguments here'' 
- 
- 
- 
- 
- 
Line 72: Line 64:
|WRITE CONTENT FOR THE "YES" BOX ABOVE THIS CODE width="45%" bgcolor="#F2FAFB" style="border:1px solid #BAC5FD;padding:.4em;padding-top: 0.5em;"| |WRITE CONTENT FOR THE "YES" BOX ABOVE THIS CODE width="45%" bgcolor="#F2FAFB" style="border:1px solid #BAC5FD;padding:.4em;padding-top: 0.5em;"|
====No==== ====No====
-''Click on the pencil icon and research and write arguments here'' 
- 
- 
- 
- 
- 
Line 83: Line 69:
|- |-
|WRITE CONTENT FOR THE "NO" BOX ABOVE THIS CODE colspan="2" width="45%" bgcolor="#F2F2F2" style="border:1px solid #BAC5FD;padding:.4em;padding-top: 0.5em ;"| |WRITE CONTENT FOR THE "NO" BOX ABOVE THIS CODE colspan="2" width="45%" bgcolor="#F2F2F2" style="border:1px solid #BAC5FD;padding:.4em;padding-top: 0.5em ;"|
- 
===Defining mental illness: Individuals who desire suicide are clinically insane?=== ===Defining mental illness: Individuals who desire suicide are clinically insane?===

Revision as of 16:11, 15 July 2009

Do people have a right to die and even to commit suicide?

Background and context

This debate surrounds whether individuals have a right to die, or a right to commit suicide. This debate is most relevant to the right of individuals to decide at the end of their lives that they would like to die, either by being deprived of treatment or by assisted suicide.

Right to suicide: Do individuals have a right to commit suicide?

Pro

  • People are free to commit suicide as it only harms them. As a general principle, individuals should be free to commit any act that only affects themselves, does not directly harm other citizens, and that does not damage to their surrounding environment. Suicide is one of those acts. In so far as it harms only the individual involved, the state should not intervene or make illegal.

Con

  • Suicide violates the value society places on life. There are certain things that society must value as inviolable. The dignity of life is one of those things. Outlawing suicide helps upholds this general idea of the dignity of life. Without such an expression of dignity, individuals would devalue life, and murder - among other things - would likely become more prevalent.


Death with dignity: Is prescribing lethal drugs to terminal patients justifiable?

Pro

  • Die with dignity, abandon the word euthanasia "The right to die-Essay". Ronald Sokol,Wednesday, March 21, 2007:"Every person shall have the right to die with dignity; this right shall include the right to choose the time of one's death and to receive medical and pharmaceutical assistance to die painlessly. No physician, nurse or pharmacist shall be held criminally or civilly liable for assisting a person in the free exercise of this right. Within the next half century, perhaps much sooner, the right to choose to die with dignity will be as widely recognized as the right to free speech or to exercise one's religion.It will cease to be called euthanasia or mercy killing. It will not be viewed as killing, but as a fundamental human right as expressed in the imaginary constitutional amendment above."


Con

  • Prescribing lethal drugs is violation of the doctor's healing role "Assisted suicide".By: Susan Jacoby;Source: AARP Bulletin;2005-11-10:"Doctors themselves are divided on the issue. The American Medical Association, which represents about a third of the nation's physicians, strongly opposes assisted dying. Kenneth R. Stevens Jr., M.D., a radiation oncologist in Portland, Ore., and vice president of the Physicians for Compassionate Care Education Foundation, agrees with the AMA and regards assisted suicide as a violation of the doctor's healing role. "I did not become a doctor to write a prescription to end a patient's life," he says.Stevens notes that in research reports doctors describe their patients who seek assisted death as "controlling," an attribute he says harms society as a whole. "If a person needs money," he says, "we don't say it's all right for them to go and rob a bank."


Is denial to grant right to die a power game?

Yes

  • Right to die annoys power-freaks "The right to die debate". Woody Cavenaugh,January 18, 2006 :"I always found it funny that people have a lot less trouble with killing someone, than letting someone kill themselves. Most states allow capital punishment, but to my knowledge only one or two allow assisted suicide, and only Oregon has a law allowing it outright.I believe it probably comes down to power. People want power over other people, governments want power over people, people and governments ultimately don't like it when other strange people can choose for themselves. I can do whatever I want, paint my house pink with green polka-dots for instance, but if YOU do it, I'm going homeowners association all over your weird butt."


No

Defining mental illness: Individuals who desire suicide are clinically insane?

Yes

Click on the pencil icon and research and write arguments here





No

Click on the pencil icon and research and write arguments here


  • Argument: Suicide does not equal insanity| Suicide does not equal insanity Lawrence Stevens "SUICIDE: A Civil Right". The Antipsychiatry Coalition. : "Furthermore, there isn't any good evidence that mental illness by any generally accepted definition is usually involved in a person's decision to commit suicide. In her book about teenage suicide, Marion Crook, B.Sc.N., says "teens considering suicide are not necessarily mentally disturbed. In fact, they are rarely mentally disturbed" (Every Parent's Guide To Understanding Teenagers & Suicide, Int'l Self-Counsel Press Ltd., Vancouver, 1988, p. 10). Psychologist Paul G. Quinnett, Ph.D., makes this observation in his book Suicide: The Forever Decision: "As we have already discussed, however, you do not have to be mentally ill to take your own life. In fact, most people who do commit suicide are not legally `insane.'"




External links

Problem with the site? 

Tweet a bug on bugtwits
.